When it comes to mortgages, having to decide between open and closed alternatives may be likened to being at a crossroads and not knowing which way to go. Many homeowners need clarification as each alternative has unique advantages and factors to take into account.
You’re not the only one who has been wondering about the distinctions between open and closed mortgages. Knowing these two different routes is crucial, regardless of whether you’re an experienced homeowner thinking about a refinance or a first-time buyer navigating the maze of mortgage financing.
Let’s take a closer look at open vs closed mortgages and discuss their distinct features, benefits, and drawbacks in this blog post. We’ll look at how each choice compares, from the stability of closed mortgages to the flexibility of open mortgages.
A Closed Mortgage: What is it?
In a closed mortgage, the criteria and conditions are predetermined and cannot be changed without resultant penalties. Following your approval, the terms are fixed for the length of the mortgage term, which can range from six months to ten years (five years is a popular duration among Canadians).
Although a closed mortgage offers security, it also limits adaptability. Prepayment alternatives might be available to you, such as the ability to make yearly payments equal to a predetermined percentage of the original principal amount. However, you can be penalized and charged for breaching the agreement if you have to sell your house or make adjustments to your mortgage before the term is over.
How do Prepayment Penalties Work for Closed Mortgage?
An early termination of a closed fixed-rate mortgage will probably result in an interest rate differential (IRD) penalty. The amount of interest that is left on the term is used to compute this penalty. A larger penalty will be imposed if a closed fixed-rate mortgage is broken sooner in the term.
The prepayment penalty for a closed variable-rate mortgage is usually equal to three months’ interest.
The costs of terminating a closed mortgage can be considerable since they help lenders get back lost money while continuing to offer mortgages at cheap interest rates. Closed mortgages are common because of their cheap interest rates, but there is some risk for homeowners because of the prepayment penalties that come with them.
What is an Open Mortgage?
Borrowers have more options with an open mortgage than with a closed one. Due to this flexibility, borrowers may reduce the length of their mortgage and reduce their interest costs by increasing their regular payments and making additional one-time deposits without facing penalties.
But in comparison to closed mortgages, this flexibility usually entails higher interest rates. There are circumstances in which an open mortgage could be beneficial, even though paying more interest might not seem appropriate. For example, an open mortgage can avoid prepayment penalties if you plan to sell your house before the mortgage term expires or if you anticipate receiving a sizable amount of money.
It’s important to remember that although open mortgages provide flexibility, there may be administrative fees associated with specific activities for borrowers. Therefore, before agreeing to an open mortgage, it is imperative that you fully comprehend its terms and circumstances.
Pros and Cons of Open and Closed Mortgages
| Pros | Cons | |
| Open Mortgages | Pay Off Faster: Allows you to pay off your mortgage faster without penalties. Flexible Payments: Enables you to increase monthly payments or make lump-sum payments with minimal penalties. Cost-Effective Refinancing: Cheaper and more flexible option for refinancing your mortgage. | Higher Rates: Open mortgages often have higher interest rates. Rate Fluctuation Risk: They expose you to the risk of interest rate changes. |
| Closed Mortgages | Lower Rates: Closed mortgages offer lower interest rates. Rate Stability: They provide more stable rates, shielding you from fluctuations. | Limited Flexibility: Closed mortgages restrict paying off the mortgage faster without penalties. Penalty Risks: Penalties for increasing payments or making lump-sum payments. Costly Refinancing: They can be expensive and challenging to refinance. |
Advantage of Lower Interest Rates in Closed Mortgages
Closed mortgages provide lower interest rates than open mortgages, even with their drawbacks, like the inability to refinance or move lenders without incurring fines. One of the main reasons closed mortgages are becoming more and more popular in Canada is the reduced interest rate. Furthermore, since closed mortgage rates are usually more appealing than the higher rates linked to open mortgages, they are highlighted in the majority of mortgage rate marketing.
Variable closed mortgage: What is it?
When it comes to a variable-closed mortgage, the interest rate is determined by the prime rate of the bank, which is impacted by ongoing market conditions. With a variable-closed mortgage, you could save money on interest if market interest rates drop. This is in contrast to fixed-rate mortgages, where the interest rate stays the same for the duration of the loan.
Variable closed mortgages, like fixed closed mortgages, have prepayment restrictions because they are closed mortgages. However, they frequently have smaller prepayment penalties, which are usually computed using interest accrued over three months. On the other hand, penalties for closed fixed-rate mortgages are typically calculated as the difference between the interest rate that would apply after three months or as an “interest rate differential” that represents the difference between the fixed-rate mortgage and current market rates. Variable-closed mortgages may be more flexible for borrowers who may need to make prepayments or pay off their mortgage early due to this variation in penalty calculation.
Choosing Between Open vs Closed Mortgage
A number of important considerations must be made when choosing between open vs closed mortgages:
- Do you anticipate receiving a sizable windfall or inheritance in the near future that you may use to pay off your mortgage early?
- Before your mortgage term expires, do you intend to move or sell your house?
- Do you think your household’s income will rise to the point where you can afford a bigger monthly mortgage payment?
If any of these questions apply to you, going with an open mortgage may be a good idea because it can help you avoid paying hefty costs if you decide to terminate the loan early.
As an alternative, you could look at short-term convertible mortgages, which have interest rates that fall between those of closed and open mortgages and usually last six months. You can extend a convertible mortgage at the new rate as needed. You can convert to a longer-term option at a later time, once things settle down or interest rates go down.
Because closed mortgage rates are cheaper, many homeowners choose them, particularly if they intend to stay in their houses for the duration of the mortgage. Whichever way you decide, it’s critical to comprehend the terms and conditions of your mortgage to prevent unpleasant surprises down the road in case things change.
Summing Up
The main distinction between open vs closed mortgages is how flexible and stable they are. Closed mortgages have fixed terms and lower interest rates, but they also have less flexibility and may have early repayment penalties. Open mortgages, on the other hand, offer more freedom and don’t charge penalties for early repayments, even though they have higher interest rates. It’s crucial to take your financial objectives and situation into account while deciding between the two to find the one that best suits your requirements. Ultimately, the choice of the best mortgage for your route to homeownership will depend on how much stability or flexibility you value.
Leave a Reply